Skip to main content

First Time Playing: Knave

Knave is a rules-lite tabletop rpg written by Ben Milton of Questing Beast (and available here). It's OSR compatible, incredibly easy to teach, and even easier to run. Between reading its seven-page rulebook, and rolling characters, you and your players will be dungeoneering and adventuring within minutes. For starters, it's a fairly standard d20+mod roll-over system (as in, roll higher than a target number). If you're experienced with Dungeons & Dragons 5e or Pathfinder, more than anything you're going to be spending more time unlearning things than having to learn anything new.

What I loved
For being so lightweight, it's actually pretty hard to pick a feature that I love the most. Every mechanic and rule within the book has purpose and weight, and is balanced well within the system. Things just make sense. Each of its six traditional ability scores (Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom, Charisma) share equal importance so there's never an immediate dump stat. It's classless, but instead of everyone feeling the same, it gives a sense of freedom to let players develop and design their own characters in their own way, relying on what they want to do instead of what abilities they're given to set themselves apart.

That being said, I think the way Knave handles spellcasting is my absolute favorite thing about this system. Technically, anyone can cast spells as they are available in the form of spellbooks. Each spellbook takes a single inventory slot (which are very limited) and allows a single casting per day. Spellbooks also require two hands to use. Mechanically and thematically, this does an amazing job of helping players feel like an actual wizard or fledgling magic-user and reinforces the trope of giving up a weapon, or carrying certain tools and armor in order to wield the power of magic spells.

The spells themselves are widely flavorful, and can be quite powerful in a creative players hands. Knave features 100 level-less spells, but once you read them it's incredibly easy to come up with your own (or borrow the tables from Ben Milton's other game, Maze Rats). My favorite is probably Summon Idol, in which the caster calls forth a carved stone statue the size of a four-post bed from the ground.

Aside from the spellcasting, I think the thing that draws me to this system is just how hackable it is. It's so rules-lite, it's almost a chassis of an rpg, in a good way. If you already have a laundry list of houserules or preferred systems of handling certain rulings (like chases, combat stunts or maneuvers, etc) then more than likely you can port it over and tack it on with no problems. You can hack together a new magic system, alter the current one, or bolt together one from a different system with relative ease. I myself have written a hack called Knacks, or a way for characters to develop different specialties in this post here.

Next Time I Play
Although I love modding and hacking rpgs, whenever I run something the first time, I try to play it as the designer intended it to get an idea for the game itself before making things my own. Next time I run it, I'll definitely be implementing my aforementioned Knack-hack. Also, the players I play with tend to really focus on interpersonal relationships among their characters, so I might try adding some alternate methods of gaining XP through something like bonds and resolving them (similar to Dungeon World's bonds system).

Final Thoughts
In the weeks reading up on it and preparing our first game, and even just after it, I'm still infatuated with Knave. It's my first foray into the OSR / D&D retroclone space, and my players and I all had a blast with it, already trying to schedule our next play date. For its mechanics, its tables, and its production value it's a steal to be honest. On top of providing a great system of play, there's something about its simplicity and directness that lights those creative lighter fluids on fire for any would-be designer or GM.

Comments

  1. Sounds pretty fun, especially the magic part. I'm not a big fan of the D&D magic system and would like to check out more approaches to it.

    I'm curious about the progression of a classless system. How do the characters specialize themselves?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In the core game, as you progress you can choose a number of the six ability scores to increase. Because inventory is so limited, specialization then relies mostly on what arms and equipment you choose to take with you, whether that be tools, the type of armor / weapons you use, or spellbooks (since spells take inventory slots).

      Delete
  2. Thanks for this review! Glad you're enjoying the game.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Of course! I'm looking forward to getting more sessions in. On top of that, I can't stop thinking of more tables to make for this system.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Knave-Knacks

Knave is a great chassis of an rpg for modding and hacking, and it seems that the first thing that most game designers see is a need for class customization in an otherwise classless system. I'm no different. Here's a stab in the dark at trying to add a little more character customization.

Knacks
As characters level, they reveal themselves to either have obtained or show a natural knack for different aspects of dungeoneering. At levels 3, 6, and 9, instead of increasing three abilities by one point, they increase a single ability by one point and roll on one of the following tables. (I guess your players can pick one if they want, but rolling is usually more fun, and that's what matters). 




Fighting
      +1 boon on attack rolls+1 boon on stuntsDeal damage equal to your Strength on a successful stuntIgnore losing 1 point of quality on armor or extra damage when an attacker rolls a 20 (or you roll a 1 to defend). When wielding two weapons, roll damage dice for both weapons on a …

Making Fun of Magic (part 1)

This is the beginning of a series of posts that addresses what I like to call, "No-Fun Magic". To me, "No-Fun Magic" are spells and abilities that don't necessarily add anything to the game, interact in any meaningful way, and whose purpose is solely to skip a part of the game or act as a specific answer to another magic spell. Although this can be applied to any game where these spells exists, this series is a direct response to my time spent playing Dungeons & Dragons 5e, so take that as you will.

First up on the chopping block is the 3rd level Abjuration spell Dispel Magic. I like it because it's a classic, both in D&D and fantasy fiction in general. Wizards cast spells and sometimes those are bad spells. Other wizards then casts spells to undo those bad things. Or vice versa, good and bad are just words. Whatever. What I don't like about it (at least, in D&D 5e) is how boring it is. If there's a magical barrier or trap, then as long…